An emergency room physician in Dallas with 40 years of experience had his individual disability insurance claim denied twice by Unum despite a progressive cognitive decline that made it unsafe for him to continue practicing emergency medicine. He turned to Dabdoub Law Firm, where Attorney Geannina Burgos built a forceful demand backed by unanimous medical consensus from his treating physicians, objective neuropsychological testing, and an independent expert review. Unum reversed its position and approved his disability claim in full.
What to Know About This Case:
- A Dallas, Texas, emergency room physician with four decades of experience was forced to stop practicing after a progressive cognitive decline led to a dangerous clinical error, and Unum denied his individual disability claim twice despite uniform medical agreement that he could no longer safely treat patients.
- Attorney Geannina Burgos built a compelling demand supported by his treating internist, his treating neurologist, objective neuropsychological testing, and an independent neuropsychologist’s file review, all reaching the same conclusion.
- Dabdoub Law Firm secured approval of our client’s individual disability claim without the need for litigation.
Veteran ER Physician Needs Disability Insurance Benefits
Our client spent four decades practicing emergency medicine, earning board certification through the American Board of Emergency Medicine and recognition as a fellow of the American College of Emergency Physicians for more than 30 years. Emergency medicine is a specialty that leaves no room for error, demanding constant vigilance, rapid information processing, flawless judgment, and the ability to manage multiple critically ill patients simultaneously without mistake.
Beginning in mid-to-late 2025, our client began experiencing a progressive decline in his cognitive functioning. The moment that made the danger unmistakable came in September 2025, during an emergency department shift, when he became confused, misidentified a coworker, and later realized he had made a clinical decision involving a patient that he could not explain or account for. Rather than risk harm to a patient, our client immediately removed himself from practice. He sought medical evaluation right away, and his longtime primary care physician, who had treated him for years and had never observed any sign of exaggeration, malingering, or substance misuse, recommended an immediate medical leave due to the risk of patient harm.
A treating neurologist followed our client over multiple visits across several months, documenting progressively worsening short-term memory, confusion with routine tasks, impaired judgment, and a growing dependence on his wife for financial and household management. Though testing ruled out Alzheimer’s disease, the neurologist diagnosed a progressive cognitive disorder of a different origin and stated unequivocally that it would not be safe for our client to return to emergency medicine. Formal neuropsychological testing confirmed an objective decline from our client’s previously superior cognitive baseline, revealing impairments in executive functioning, visuospatial reasoning, learning, and delayed recall.
Attorney Burgos Secured Approval Against a Unanimous Medical Record
Unum denied our client’s claim twice, relying on the absence of Alzheimer’s pathology, normal imaging results, and preserved basic daily activities, factors that had nothing to do with the actual question of whether our client could perform the important duties of emergency medicine specifically. Attorney Geannina Burgos built her demand around exposing that mismatch, making clear that an ER physician does not need to be unable to manage basic daily tasks to be totally disabled from his own occupation. He simply needs to be unable to perform emergency medicine safely and reliably.
To reinforce that argument, Attorney Burgos commissioned an independent neuropsychological file review from a board-certified clinical neuropsychologist, who concluded after reviewing the raw testing data and medical records that our client could not work as an emergency room physician, or in any similar role, on a consistent, reliable, and safe basis. The reviewer explained that his documented deficits in executive functioning, decision-making, error recognition, and memory would directly interfere with patient care, multitasking, and the time-critical clinical decisions emergency medicine demands every day.
Attorney Burgos paired this independent review with corroborating firsthand accounts from our client’s wife and adult daughter, who each independently described the same pattern of cognitive decline, forgotten conversations, confusion about long-held professional responsibilities, and behavior entirely inconsistent with his prior functioning. With his treating internist, his treating neurologist, formal neuropsychological testing, an independent expert review, and his own family all reaching the identical conclusion, Unum’s denial could not withstand scrutiny. The insurer reversed its position and approved our client’s individual disability claim in full, without the matter proceeding to litigation.
Lawyers with Expertise in Disability Insurance Claims & Appeals
At Dabdoub Law Firm, disability insurance is all we do. We represent clients nationwide and have successfully handled disability insurance claims involving:
- Long-term disability denials and appeals
- Individual disability insurance claims
- Depression and anxiety disorders
- Cognitive impairment and memory loss
- Neurological conditions
- Medication side effects
We have taken on every major insurance company and have built a proven track record of success, including victories in federal court.
Because we specialize in long-term disability, our clients get the benefit of:
- Having an attorney who is an expert in long-term disability claims;
- Having an attorney who has experience with every major disability insurance company; and
- Being backed by a law firm that has a proven track record of winning tough disability lawsuits.
Need Help with a Disability Insurance Claim?
If your disability claim has been denied or you are struggling to navigate the claims process, we can help.
We help with:
- Filing a disability insurance claim
- Appealing denied or terminated long-term disability benefits
- Negotiating a lump-sum settlement
- Filing a lawsuit against your disability insurance company
We represent clients nationwide and charge no fees unless we win your case.
Call (800) 969-0488 or contact us online to speak with an experienced disability attorney. Pay no fees or costs unless you get paid.